Pipe Relining vs. Replacement: Which Is Better
Dealing with a blocked sewer pipe is stressful, right? It disrupts your daily routine, makes your home smell funky, and can lead to further damage with aging pipes throughout your home.
We get it! Any plumbing issue can wreak havoc! So, if you’re facing aging or damaged pipes, you might be wondering whether to go for pipe relining vs replacement.
Fret not. Adelaide Emergency Plumbing is here to help!
Choosing the right method depends on your specific situation, including the severity of the blockage and your budget. Let’s break these options down so you can make the best choice for your home and peace of mind.
Understanding Sewer Pipe Repair or Replacement Options
Get ready to dig deep into Pipe Relining and Pipe Replacement because by the end of this blog, you will probably have the best solution for your needs.
What is Pipe Relining?
Pipe relining, also known as cured-in-place pipe (CIPP) relining, is a modern, less disruptive way to fix your pipes. This one is usually an easy fix!
Here’s how it works: Our expert plumbers at Adelaide Emergency Plumbing insert a flexible liner coated with resin into your existing pipe. It is then inflated and cured, creating a new, sturdy pipe inside the old one. This drain pipe relining method seals leaks and strengthens weak spots, all without tearing up your yard or landscaping.
What is Pipe Replacement?
Pipe replacement is the more traditional route. It means digging up your old pipes and installing new ones. This is usually the go-to when your pipes are severely damaged or beyond repair.
It’s thorough, but it also means more mess and a higher cost due to the excavation and installation work.
Which is Better: Pipe Relining Vs Replacement?
When deciding between plumbing pipe relining and replacement, you have to consider these factors:
| Factor | Pipe Relining | Pipe Replacement |
| Cost | Reline sewer pipe is generally cheaper. Avoids excavation and major disruptions. | It can be more expensive due to digging and new pipe installation. |
| Time and Disruption | Faster and less disruptive. Most jobs are done within a day. | Takes longer and is more disruptive. It can stretch over several days. |
| Effectiveness | Great for fixing leaks, cracks, and minor damage. Suitable for moderate to severe issues. | Best for seriously damaged or corroded pipes. Provides a fresh start. |
| Longevity | Typically, it lasts up to 50 years, depending on the pipe’s condition and materials. | New pipes can last over 50 years, offering a long-term solution. |
| Environmental Impact | More eco-friendly. Reduces digging and minimises soil disruption. | Involves significant digging, which can disturb landscaping and has a higher impact. |
This should give you an idea of which solution would be ideal for your needs. If not, keep reading!
How to Know if Pipe Relining Vs Replacement is Right for You
Let’s get into details; these are the 4 factors that will help you find the right solution.
- Extent of Damage:
If your pipes just have a few cracks or leaks, relining might be enough. For severe damage like extensive corrosion or collapse, replacement might be necessary. - Budget:
Relining is usually less expensive and less disruptive. This is a good solution if you’re looking to save on costs and avoid digging. However, if your budget allows you to do a complete overhaul, a replacement might be the best option. - Pipe Location:
This one is super important! If your pipes are in tricky spots or near your landscaping, relining is less invasive. But, replacement can involve more digging, which can mess up your yard or driveway and create a messy environment. - Long-Term Plans:
Are you planning to stay here for years to come? Or do you need a temporary fix?
Think about your future plans for the home. If you’re doing major renovations, replacement might be better for a long-term fix.
Consult a Professional:
Still unsure? Here’s the best way to decide: Call an emergency plumber in Adelaide at (08) 8004 5957.
They’ll help you weigh immediate repairs against long-term benefits.
Signs You Need Sewer Pipe Replacement or Repair
But before that, watch out for these red flags that can indicate a problem:
- Frequent Clogs: Constant blockages can indicate underlying pipe problems.
- Slow Drains: If water’s draining slowly, it might be a sign of a partial blockage or damage.
- Unpleasant Odors: Sewer smells inside or outside your home could mean damaged pipes or leaks.
- Water Damage: Water stains or damp areas might signal a leaking or burst pipe.
Now if you’ve decided that you want to opt for sewer line replacement or sewer relining, here are some pros and cons to each method!
Pros and Cons of Pipe Relining and Replacement
| Pipe Relining | Pipe Replacement |
| Pros | Pros |
| Reline sewer pipe won’t require you to dig up your lawn or flooring, minimising disruption. | Complete Solution – Completely remove and replace the damaged pipe. |
| Reduced labour and material costs make it more affordable than replacement. | A fresh start with new pipes that will last for decades. |
| A quicker completion time – The process is usually completed within a day or two. | |
| The lifespan of a new liner can reach 50 years with proper maintenance. | |
| Cons | Cons |
| This may not be suitable for severely damaged or collapsed pipes. | Labour and materials costs associated with digging and installing new pipes are higher. |
| It may take several days or longer to complete the job. |
6 Reasons Why Sewer Pipe Relining Beats Traditional Repair
If you’re weighing sewer pipe relining against traditional repair methods, here’s why relining might be the better pick:
- Stronger Pipes: Relining adds a new, sturdy layer inside your old pipes, increasing their strength.
- Handles Tight Spots: It’s flexible enough to navigate tricky pipe layouts and bends.
- Stops Root Intrusions: The seamless liner prevents pesky roots from getting in.
- Less Utility Disruption: Fewer interruptions to water and gas services with minimal digging.
- Tech-Savvy: Uses advanced cameras for precise diagnostics before and after repairs.
- Keeps Your Yard Intact: Avoids major digging, so your landscaping stays put.
In short, sewer relining offers a modern, efficient fix that saves time, hassle, and keeps your property looking great!
If you’re looking for a solution that gets the job done without the mess, it’s definitely worth considering.
Deciding Between Pipe Relining Vs Replacement?
If you’re still thinking, is pipe relining worth it? Here’s a quick guide.
If your pipes are old or made from outdated materials, they might need sewer line replacement. For minor issues like small cracks or leaks, relining can often be a cost-effective fix. However, if the damage is extensive or you’re dealing with persistent blockages, pipe replacement might be a better choice.
Relining is generally cheaper and less disruptive compared to replacement, which involves more digging and higher costs. While relining can extend your pipe’s life, replacement offers a fresh start with a new system.
Still unsure? Call Adelaide Emergency Plumbing at (08) 8004 5957
Relining is ideal for minor issues and involves less disruption, while the replacement is suited for extensive damage and provides a longer-term solution. To make the best choice for your plumbing needs, consult with a professional plumber. They’ll help you balance immediate repairs with long-term benefits.
At Adelaide Emergency Plumbing, we specialise in providing prompt and reliable plumbing solutions tailored to your needs. Also, our experts can help you to understand the difference between pipe relining vs replacement and pick the best option for you.
Contact us today to schedule a consultation and ensure your plumbing is in top shape!
